Blue Water Agency - Logo

The Blue Water Agency team is your local source for risk control services and insurance solutions. We take pride in offering five-star support to all our customers throughout the Millstone area. Our experienced agents have the expertise to customize policies for your auto, home, health, and business insurance requirements.

We believe in a partnership approach that creates a lasting relationship with each of our customers. Our goal is to provide the right coverage at the lowest possible cost. The time is now to put the Blue Water Agency team to work for you. Call or click today for a FREE assessment of your current coverage needs.

QUICK QUOTE

HOME INSURANCE

Whether you Rent or Own, make sure your home and belongings are protected. Let us help you find the right protection with a rate you can afford.

HOME QUOTE

Use this FREE tool to shop for the best insurance rates available online. Unlike other insurance sites you may have come across, we will NEVER sell your information. That means you get fast and accurate quotes without any hassle.

AUTO INSURANCE

With all the options out there, finding the right Auto coverage can be overwhelming. Our experienced agents have the expertise to narrow down your options and get you the lowest rate.

AUTO QUOTE

Use this FREE tool to shop for the best insurance rates available online. Unlike other insurance sites you may have come across, we will NEVER sell your information. That means you get fast and accurate quotes without any hassle.

LIFE INSURANCE

Having the right Life Insurance is a very important decision for you and your family. Our experts will help you choose the right coverage to make sure your family is protected.

LIFE QUOTE

Use this FREE tool to shop for the best insurance rates available online. Unlike other insurance sites you may have come across, we will NEVER sell your information. That means you get fast and accurate quotes without any hassle.

How can we help you today? Let the Blue Water Agency team help you find the right coverage for your insurance needs.

Work with agents that care.

Experience Matters
Our experts will shop your insurance needs to find the most affordable coverage available.

Auto Insurance

Use this FREE self-help tool to quickly shop for the best auto insurance rates available. Work with EXPERT agents that will make sure you have the right coverage.

Business Insurance

Protect your Business Assets. Use this FREE self-help tool to quickly shop for the best business insurance rates available. Work with EXPERT agents that will make sure you have the right coverage.

Home Insurance

Make sure your BIGGEST investment is protected. Use this FREE self-help tool to quickly shop for the best home owners insurance rates available. Work with EXPERT agents that will make sure you have the right coverage.

Life Insurance

Life Insurance is extremely important to you and your family’s well being. Use this FREE self-help tool to quickly shop for the best life insurance rates available. Get accurate quotes from EXPERT agents that will make sure you have the right coverage.

Renters Insurance

Renters insurance can protect you and your belongings from theft, fire, water damage, accidents, and more. Our expert agents will make sure you only pay for what you need. See how affordable renters insurance can be.

Flood Insurance

Blue Water Agency will provide you with rates from multiple insurance companies to help you shop for the best combination of price and coverage and clearly explain the options, so you can make the best decision on which plan works best for you.

Speciality Insurance

Blue Water Agency will provide you with rates from multiple insurance companies to help you shop for the best combination of price and coverage and clearly explain the options, so you can make the best decision on which plan works best for you.

The Blue Water Agency Team

Start your insurance purchase process here!

The Blue Water Agency team will shop your policy needs to multiple carriers to find you the lowest possible rate combined with the best coverage. Let us help you make a smart decision.

Explore Our Merchant Marketplace

Browse featured listings in the different neighborhoods in our area.

What our clients are saying

  • Great Agancy and timely service!

    Samy Bassily Avatar Samy Bassily
    April 30, 2025

    Steve was very helpful and professional in finding us insurance that met our needs

    Linda Pniewski Avatar Linda Pniewski
    March 2, 2025

    Steve is the best!

    Marc LaMonica Avatar Marc LaMonica
    November 30, 2024

    Best most friendly service. I will and do recommend them to everyone !

    Jesse Boyce Avatar Jesse Boyce
    October 30, 2024
  • Steve is the best. No matter what I ask him, he always comes through with the sharpest rate. Simply put, he is the best in the biz!

    Patrick Keelen Avatar Patrick Keelen
    September 30, 2024

    Steve quickly found me a better price for homeowners after mine went up 500.00. He has access to many companies, so was able to quote me a good price. Steve... read more

    Carol S Avatar Carol S
    May 30, 2024

    I have been doing business with Steve for a number of years. He is very accommodating, professional and hard working. He deals with so many different insurance companies... read more

    H Topal Avatar H Topal
    May 30, 2024

    Nice hard working people, thank you

    Murray Dychtwald Avatar Murray Dychtwald
    May 30, 2024
  • Very professional. Provided updates along the way.

    Joel Bloom Avatar Joel Bloom
    May 30, 2024

    Fast and Convenient Service really guided us a new business.

    Patrick Devine Avatar Patrick Devine
    May 30, 2024

    Top Notch agency that can find you the best insurance at the best price. Dion explains coverages so its easy to understand and makes sure you're properly quoted. I was... read more

    Eric Hasenpusch Avatar Eric Hasenpusch
    May 30, 2023

    Blue Water Agency has gone above and beyond identifying the best solutions for me and my company. They are personable, professional, and truly care which is incredibly difficult to... read more

    Frank Vicendese Avatar Frank Vicendese
    May 30, 2023